When it comes to Cricut machines, two models consistently spark debate: the Cricut Explore Air 2 and the Cricut Explore 3.
Both machines are part of Cricut’s mid-range lineup, designed for hobbyists, DIY crafters, and small business owners who need reliable cutting performance.
At first glance, the machines appear similar, but there are key differences in speed, cutting ability, and overall value.
This guide breaks down those differences to help you decide which model is right for your crafting goals, whether that’s making stickers, custom decals, or personalized gifts.
Table of Contents
1. Cutting Speed and Performance
The speed of your cutting machine can make a significant difference, especially if you produce large quantities of stickers or vinyl projects.
Cricut Explore Air 2: This machine includes “Fast Mode,” which allows it to cut and write up to twice as fast as the original Explore series. While this is sufficient for most home crafters, it can feel limiting if you are producing in bulk or handling large custom orders.
Cricut Explore 3: The Explore 3 offers an even greater speed advantage, cutting up to twice as fast as the Explore Air 2 when using Smart Materials. This makes it much more efficient for anyone running a craft shop or producing long, repetitive cuts.
Verdict: If you primarily craft for personal enjoyment, the Air 2’s speed is more than adequate.
If you plan to monetize your projects or regularly handle large batches, the Explore 3 will save time and improve productivity.
2. Mat vs. Matless Cutting
How you load your materials into the machine affects both convenience and cost.
Explore Air 2: Requires a cutting mat for all projects, regardless of material. This adds an extra step to every project but also allows more flexibility in choosing third-party materials like Royal Elements printable vinyl and heat transfer vinyl. Mats need to be replaced periodically, which can add to ongoing costs.
Explore 3: The major advancement here is compatibility with Cricut Smart Materials. These allow for matless cutting, meaning you can load vinyl directly into the machine for projects up to 12 feet long. For banner makers or small businesses that create large decals, this can be a major benefit.
Verdict: If you often work with smaller sheets, sticker paper, or third-party vinyl, both machines work equally well.
If you see value in matless cutting with Smart Materials, the Explore 3 offers a big convenience factor.
3. Material Compatibility
Both machines are designed to handle a wide variety of crafting materials.
Explore Air 2: Cuts over 100 different materials including cardstock, standard vinyl, HTV, adhesive foil, and more. It is fully compatible with third-party supplies such as Royal Elements printable vinyl sheets, laminating sheets, and waterslide decal paper.
Explore 3: Cuts the same 100+ materials but extends functionality with Smart Materials. The ability to cut longer lengths without a mat gives it an edge for larger projects.
Verdict: For everyday crafting, both machines provide the same material versatility.
The Explore 3’s Smart Material compatibility is most valuable if you plan to use Cricut’s proprietary products for large projects.
4. Software & Connectivity
Both machines are powered by Cricut Design Space, the company’s cloud-based software that allows you to design projects and send them to your cutter.
Explore Air 2: Fully compatible with Design Space and available on desktop and mobile. Supports both USB and Bluetooth connectivity.
Explore 3: Uses the same software but benefits from being a newer release, which means it is likely to receive longer support and updates. Bluetooth connectivity is built-in, making wireless use seamless.
Verdict: Both machines are similar in this category.
The Explore 3 has a slight advantage when thinking long-term, since Cricut will continue to prioritize updates for newer models.
5. Price & Value
The cost of the machine is often the deciding factor for new crafters.
Cricut Explore Air 2: Typically retails under $200 when on sale. It’s a budget-friendly option for beginners who want professional cutting capabilities without the higher price tag.
Cricut Explore 3: Sells between $250–$300 depending on sales and bundles. The higher cost is justified by faster cutting speeds and the ability to work without a mat.
Verdict: The Explore Air 2 is excellent for those just getting started or crafting casually.
The Explore 3 is worth the extra cost if you plan to sell products, run a business, or value speed and efficiency.
Final Verdict
Choose the Cricut Explore Air 2 if you are a beginner, crafting primarily for personal use, or working with standard materials like printable vinyl sticker sheets and HTV.
Choose the Cricut Explore 3 if you are running a small business, want faster production, or need the ability to work with long, matless Smart Materials.
Both machines deliver excellent performance, and both work perfectly with Royal Elements printable vinyl, laminating sheets, and waterslide decal paper to produce high-quality, professional results.
